MOT Risk Index.co.uk

Which cars fail their MOT most in Dudley (DY)?

In the Dudley (DY) postcode area, 481 models had 100 or more initial MOT tests (first attempts) in 2019–2024 (1,243,382 tests). The Audi S3 fails most above its own rate elsewhere in Britain: 29.8% here against 20.7% (+9.1 points, 95% interval +1.0 to +17.2; a rough estimate from 124 tests here). The Nissan Elgrand does best against its own rate (−15.4 points). Rates are not age-adjusted: the age of each model's cars can differ between areas.

Data release dvsa-2024-v2 (24 Sep 2026) · page updated 30 Sep 2026 · all 119 postcode areas · check a car by registration

Every model with 100+ tests in Dudley (DY)

Each model is set against its own first-time failure rate in the rest of Britain over the same years; the table runs from the largest excess to the largest shortfall.

Dudley (DY): first-time MOT failure by model against the same model elsewhere in Britain (2019–2024, not age-adjusted)
ModelFailed here, %Elsewhere in Britain, %Difference, points95% intervalTests here
Audi S329.820.7+9.1+1.0 to +17.2124 (rough estimate)
Chevrolet Orlando48.740.0+8.6−0.5 to +17.8115 (rough estimate)
Toyota Proace38.330.7+7.6+1.4 to +13.8235 (rough estimate)
Suzuki Liana57.449.8+7.5−1.3 to +16.4122 (rough estimate)
SsangYong Tivoli31.024.0+7.0−0.6 to +14.7142 (rough estimate)
Mercedes-Benz V-Class24.617.9+6.6−1.4 to +14.7110 (rough estimate)
SsangYong Rexton44.438.0+6.4−2.7 to +15.5115 (rough estimate)
Mitsubishi Space Star61.054.7+6.3+0.4 to +12.3264 (rough estimate)
Fiat Grande Punto49.043.5+5.5−1.4 to +12.4202 (rough estimate)
Renault Koleos35.630.2+5.5−3.9 to +14.8101 (rough estimate)
Nissan e-NV20030.425.0+5.4−3.0 to +13.9115 (rough estimate)
Lexus RX25.420.1+5.3+1.9 to +8.8621
Volkswagen Sharan33.728.6+5.1+1.6 to +8.7682
Subaru XV21.216.3+4.9−2.1 to +11.9132 (rough estimate)
Jeep Compass30.025.2+4.9−0.8 to +10.5253 (rough estimate)
Peugeot Expert42.337.7+4.5+2.8 to +6.33,055
MG 639.134.6+4.5−0.2 to +9.3417 (rough estimate)
Mercedes-Benz Sprinter32.728.3+4.5+0.9 to +8.0675
Saab 9-542.838.4+4.4−2.1 to +10.9222 (rough estimate)
Citroen C4 Cactus26.422.2+4.2+0.7 to +7.8594
Chevrolet Trax32.328.1+4.1−4.1 to +12.4124 (rough estimate)
Jeep Wrangler32.328.2+4.1−3.2 to +11.4158 (rough estimate)
Peugeot 300832.228.1+4.0+2.7 to +5.44,806
Tesla Model 319.915.9+3.9+0.2 to +7.7433 (rough estimate)
Peugeot 500837.433.5+3.9+0.5 to +7.3792
Citroen C539.335.4+3.9+0.3 to +7.5717
Rover 7548.644.7+3.9+0.8 to +6.91,048
Mercedes-Benz Citan38.434.6+3.7−0.3 to +7.8560
Honda HR-V18.014.5+3.6−0.1 to +7.3416 (rough estimate)
Peugeot Partner40.136.7+3.3+2.0 to +4.75,240
Abarth 50034.631.4+3.2−3.7 to +10.1185 (rough estimate)
Renault Kangoo49.346.1+3.2+1.2 to +5.12,652
DS DS427.824.8+3.0−5.4 to +11.5108 (rough estimate)
Volkswagen Crafter32.930.0+3.0−4.5 to +10.4155 (rough estimate)
Ford Capri23.420.5+2.9−5.0 to +10.8111 (rough estimate)
Rover 2544.742.0+2.7−0.7 to +6.1817
Peugeot 20538.235.6+2.6−4.7 to +9.9170 (rough estimate)
SEAT Exeo33.931.3+2.6−4.2 to +9.3189 (rough estimate)
Mercedes-Benz Viano36.834.3+2.5−5.4 to +10.4144 (rough estimate)
Ford Edge16.113.5+2.5−2.2 to +7.3230 (rough estimate)
Porsche Cayman13.811.5+2.3−1.4 to +6.0334 (rough estimate)
Peugeot Bipper41.939.6+2.3−0.7 to +5.31,038
Honda CR-Z23.120.9+2.3−5.3 to +9.8121 (rough estimate)
Chevrolet Lacetti54.652.4+2.2−5.7 to +10.2152 (rough estimate)
Volkswagen Touareg26.123.9+2.2−0.4 to +4.81,076
Chevrolet Captiva48.846.7+2.1−2.9 to +7.1389 (rough estimate)
Vauxhall Corsavan48.746.6+2.1−5.0 to +9.2191 (rough estimate)
Fiat Stilo55.353.3+2.0−6.0 to +10.0150 (rough estimate)
Rover 21639.537.5+2.0−6.9 to +10.9119 (rough estimate)
Citroen DS535.633.6+2.0−3.8 to +7.7270 (rough estimate)
Ford Tourneo Custom19.617.7+1.9−5.8 to +9.6102 (rough estimate)
Vauxhall Combo44.642.7+1.9+0.5 to +3.44,502
BMW X118.316.4+1.9+0.3 to +3.52,189
Alfa Romeo Spider33.932.1+1.8−6.8 to +10.4118 (rough estimate)
Rover 4547.445.6+1.8−2.3 to +5.9586
Jeep Cherokee34.833.0+1.8−2.5 to +6.1477 (rough estimate)
Peugeot RCZ33.732.0+1.7−1.8 to +5.1736
MINI Hatch28.827.1+1.7+1.0 to +2.321,327
Audi TT26.625.0+1.6+0.3 to +2.94,395
MINI Paceman15.814.2+1.6−2.4 to +5.6323 (rough estimate)
BMW Z425.824.2+1.5−0.8 to +3.91,367
MINI Countryman16.815.3+1.5+0.0 to +3.02,474
BMW X525.824.3+1.5−0.3 to +3.22,416
Mitsubishi Outlander22.921.4+1.5+0.0 to +3.03,125
Ford Kuga21.219.7+1.5+0.6 to +2.38,890
Mitsubishi L20034.833.3+1.4+0.2 to +2.75,357
Suzuki Baleno21.420.0+1.3−4.3 to +7.0206 (rough estimate)
Ford Ka34.833.5+1.3+0.3 to +2.29,769
SsangYong Korando31.229.9+1.2−5.4 to +7.9186 (rough estimate)
Citroen Dispatch43.942.6+1.2−0.9 to +3.32,136
Renault Trafic43.342.1+1.2−0.3 to +2.74,303
Suzuki Vitara15.514.3+1.2−0.5 to +2.91,810
Jaguar F-Type10.29.0+1.2−2.2 to +4.5314 (rough estimate)
Lexus IS25.124.0+1.1−1.5 to +3.81,025
Land Rover Freelander34.633.5+1.1+0.0 to +2.27,391
Abarth 59519.518.4+1.1−2.2 to +4.4548
Jaguar E-Pace12.711.6+1.1−2.2 to +4.3409 (rough estimate)
BMW X322.221.1+1.1−0.8 to +2.91,897
Ford Transit Connect38.437.4+1.0−0.2 to +2.16,631
Mercedes-Benz S-Class19.018.1+0.9−2.1 to +3.9667
MG ZS16.115.2+0.9−1.2 to +3.01,161
Ford Transit37.636.7+0.9+0.0 to +1.812,092
Mitsubishi Shogun34.633.7+0.9−1.2 to +2.92,120
Audi A622.321.4+0.9−0.5 to +2.23,660
Tesla Model S16.815.9+0.9−4.6 to +6.3179 (rough estimate)
Fiat Doblo35.835.0+0.8−1.3 to +2.91,988
Nissan Primastar54.153.3+0.8−3.6 to +5.2495 (rough estimate)
Honda CR-V27.126.3+0.8−0.4 to +2.05,507
Renault Grand Scenic48.147.3+0.8−1.9 to +3.51,341
Ford Galaxy39.138.3+0.8−1.3 to +2.92,018
Citroen C4 Grand Picasso25.124.3+0.8−2.9 to +4.5530
Mazda 548.547.7+0.8−4.2 to +5.8386 (rough estimate)
Vauxhall Grandland14.113.3+0.7−0.8 to +2.31,973
Audi A716.015.3+0.7−2.8 to +4.3419 (rough estimate)
Isuzu Trooper41.540.8+0.7−6.3 to +7.8188 (rough estimate)
Land Rover Range Rover24.223.5+0.7−0.7 to +2.13,470
Hyundai ix2025.324.6+0.7−1.5 to +2.91,504
Citroen C438.537.8+0.7−0.4 to +1.87,526
BMW 5 Series23.522.8+0.7−0.4 to +1.85,654
Seat Alhambra28.527.9+0.6−2.7 to +4.0688
Lexus CT15.715.1+0.6−2.6 to +3.8497 (rough estimate)
Mitsubishi Shogun Sport44.844.2+0.6−4.3 to +5.5402 (rough estimate)
Bentley Continental10.19.5+0.6−2.6 to +3.7355 (rough estimate)
Mercedes-Benz Vito34.834.2+0.6−1.1 to +2.33,143
BMW 4 Series15.014.4+0.6−0.8 to +2.02,442
Suzuki SX429.428.8+0.6−1.7 to +2.81,611
Mitsubishi Shogun Pinin48.547.9+0.6−8.1 to +9.2130 (rough estimate)
Peugeot 20824.824.3+0.5−0.5 to +1.57,518
Vauxhall Vivaro43.543.1+0.4−0.6 to +1.49,537
Peugeot 40647.046.6+0.4−4.6 to +5.4381 (rough estimate)
Saab 9-339.639.2+0.4−2.0 to +2.71,697
Audi A520.620.3+0.4−1.0 to +1.73,624
Fiat 500L30.830.4+0.4−2.1 to +2.81,424
Ford Transit Courier28.728.3+0.3−3.3 to +3.9621
Chevrolet Cruze38.338.0+0.3−6.0 to +6.5235 (rough estimate)
Peugeot 30833.833.5+0.3−0.9 to +1.46,272
Renault Laguna48.047.7+0.3−3.4 to +3.9721
Infiniti Q3012.212.0+0.2−4.7 to +5.1172 (rough estimate)
Alfa Romeo Giulietta28.828.6+0.2−2.6 to +2.91,033
Chrysler Jeep Grand41.141.0+0.1−6.9 to +7.1192 (rough estimate)
BMW X617.317.2+0.1−3.7 to +3.9375 (rough estimate)
Hyundai Tucson17.917.8+0.1−1.0 to +1.15,032
Hyundai Santa Fe34.033.9+0.1−2.0 to +2.12,124
Ford EcoSport18.818.7+0.1−1.5 to +1.62,379
BMW 7 Series20.020.0+0.1−3.7 to +3.8449 (rough estimate)
Land Rover Range Rover Evoque16.116.0+0.0−1.0 to +1.14,828
Ford Mustang15.815.7+0.0−3.7 to +3.8362 (rough estimate)
Citroen C335.835.8+0.0−1.0 to +1.09,172
BMW X414.314.3+0.0−3.9 to +3.9314 (rough estimate)
Land Rover Discovery29.029.0+0.0−1.1 to +1.17,079
BMW 1 Series23.723.7−0.0−0.7 to +0.712,666
Peugeot 30752.452.4−0.0−1.7 to +1.63,542
Kia ProCeed29.129.1−0.0−7.0 to +6.9165 (rough estimate)
Alfa Romeo MiTo36.036.0−0.0−3.1 to +3.1929
Ford Puma14.914.9−0.1−2.3 to +2.2948
Vauxhall Cascada21.721.8−0.1−4.9 to +4.8281 (rough estimate)
MG TF32.832.9−0.1−3.3 to +3.1842
MG 321.321.4−0.1−2.1 to +2.01,548
Lexus GS21.421.4−0.1−5.9 to +5.7192 (rough estimate)
Hyundai i4025.525.6−0.1−2.5 to +2.31,288
Ford S-MAX34.234.3−0.1−2.0 to +1.82,415
BMW X215.115.2−0.1−5.4 to +5.1179 (rough estimate)
MG ZT40.840.9−0.1−5.4 to +5.2336 (rough estimate)
Mercedes-Benz GLA12.312.5−0.1−1.5 to +1.22,315
Land Rover Range Rover Sport20.921.1−0.2−1.4 to +1.14,024
Audi A325.725.9−0.2−1.0 to +0.513,019
Mercedes-Benz GLC11.211.4−0.2−1.7 to +1.31,730
Porsche Boxster18.518.7−0.2−2.5 to +2.01,178
MG HS9.910.2−0.3−4.3 to +3.8212 (rough estimate)
Toyota Hiace35.936.2−0.3−4.9 to +4.3424 (rough estimate)
Ford Focus32.632.9−0.3−0.8 to +0.139,405
MG GS17.818.1−0.3−5.9 to +5.3180 (rough estimate)
Vauxhall Mokka21.021.4−0.3−1.1 to +0.411,904
Chevrolet Aveo49.149.5−0.3−3.8 to +3.1828
Vauxhall Zafira38.538.8−0.3−1.2 to +0.512,309
Audi Q314.114.5−0.3−1.7 to +1.02,517
Peugeot 200821.521.9−0.4−1.6 to +0.93,942
Peugeot 10815.115.4−0.4−1.8 to +1.02,524
Volkswagen T-Roc8.69.0−0.4−2.1 to +1.31,016
DS 338.038.4−0.4−1.6 to +0.86,143
Nissan NV20040.641.1−0.4−3.5 to +2.61,009
MG Midget24.024.4−0.4−8.9 to +8.0100 (rough estimate)
Jeep Patriot50.450.8−0.4−9.2 to +8.3127 (rough estimate)
Toyota Previa45.546.0−0.4−8.9 to +8.0134 (rough estimate)
Kia Optima18.719.1−0.5−4.2 to +3.3412 (rough estimate)
Ford Escort27.427.8−0.5−3.4 to +2.5877
Mercedes-Benz CLA17.317.8−0.5−2.3 to +1.41,619
BMW M316.316.7−0.5−4.0 to +3.1418 (rough estimate)
Ford Ranger29.329.8−0.5−2.1 to +1.03,360
Hyundai Veloster32.633.1−0.5−7.3 to +6.3184 (rough estimate)
Ford Transit Custom20.521.0−0.5−2.5 to +1.41,688
Ford Fiesta32.733.4−0.6−1.0 to −0.355,891
Fiat 500X17.418.1−0.6−2.3 to +1.01,946
Volvo C7039.440.0−0.6−5.7 to +4.4358 (rough estimate)
Renault Megane45.746.4−0.7−1.8 to +0.57,506
Ford Mondeo34.234.8−0.7−1.6 to +0.310,096
Volkswagen Amarok20.421.0−0.7−3.7 to +2.3702
Vauxhall Viva13.013.7−0.7−2.2 to +0.81,979
Skoda Superb20.120.8−0.7−2.5 to +1.11,973
Suzuki Ignis24.325.0−0.7−3.3 to +1.91,054
Fiat Punto44.445.1−0.7−2.1 to +0.74,798
Peugeot 20747.147.9−0.7−1.8 to +0.38,794
Porsche Panamera11.612.3−0.7−6.4 to +5.0121 (rough estimate)
Hyundai Matrix46.146.8−0.7−6.1 to +4.6334 (rough estimate)
Lexus NX7.78.5−0.7−4.9 to +3.5155 (rough estimate)
Mercedes-Benz E-Class20.821.6−0.8−1.7 to +0.26,966
Nissan Pathfinder45.746.4−0.8−5.9 to +4.4357 (rough estimate)
Nissan Juke25.526.3−0.8−1.5 to −0.115,631
Toyota C-HR11.912.6−0.8−2.1 to +0.62,167
MINI Roadster16.817.6−0.8−7.7 to +6.1113 (rough estimate)
Audi A118.819.5−0.8−1.8 to +0.26,343
Volkswagen Caddy30.030.8−0.8−2.1 to +0.54,895
Mercedes-Benz A-Class20.621.4−0.8−1.6 to −0.010,759
BMW 6 Series20.321.1−0.8−3.8 to +2.2690
Nissan Leaf16.917.8−0.8−3.4 to +1.8792
Honda Civic33.334.1−0.8−1.8 to +0.19,813
Citroen Nemo39.140.0−0.9−4.5 to +2.8675
Austin Mini30.331.2−0.9−6.5 to +4.7264 (rough estimate)
Skoda Rapid20.421.3−0.9−3.2 to +1.41,188
BMW Z333.434.3−0.9−4.8 to +2.9578
Audi Q514.515.5−0.9−2.5 to +0.61,912
Volkswagen Eos32.333.3−0.9−4.7 to +2.8603
Chrysler Grand Cherokee43.144.1−1.0−6.6 to +4.7299 (rough estimate)
Ford B-MAX22.823.8−1.0−2.9 to +0.91,858
Seat Ateca10.111.1−1.0−3.1 to +1.1802
MG ZR40.341.3−1.0−6.2 to +4.2345 (rough estimate)
Toyota Land Cruiser30.331.4−1.0−4.2 to +2.1814
Skoda Kamiq9.310.4−1.1−4.6 to +2.5258 (rough estimate)
Seat Leon23.124.1−1.1−2.1 to −0.06,575
Kia Sorento31.132.2−1.1−3.0 to +0.92,226
Hyundai Terracan42.743.8−1.1−8.9 to +6.7157 (rough estimate)
Jaguar XJ23.824.9−1.1−3.7 to +1.51,041
Volvo V6020.221.3−1.1−3.2 to +1.11,349
Ford Grand C-MAX27.328.4−1.1−3.6 to +1.41,266
Mazda CX-306.57.6−1.1−4.7 to +2.5184 (rough estimate)
Daihatsu Terios38.539.7−1.1−6.9 to +4.7275 (rough estimate)
MINI Clubman14.415.6−1.2−3.8 to +1.5659
Volkswagen Tiguan16.617.8−1.2−2.1 to −0.25,751
Subaru Forester29.230.4−1.2−5.0 to +2.7531
Citroen Berlingo39.941.1−1.2−2.4 to −0.16,804
Volkswagen CC22.223.5−1.2−4.6 to +2.1598
Jeep Renegade17.718.9−1.2−3.7 to +1.3900
Ford Tourneo22.423.6−1.2−5.5 to +3.0375 (rough estimate)
Mercedes-Benz SLK24.525.7−1.3−3.0 to +0.52,404
Isuzu D-Max25.426.6−1.3−4.7 to +2.1627
Vauxhall Astra34.035.3−1.3−1.8 to −0.839,108
Mazda RX-832.233.5−1.3−9.9 to +7.2115 (rough estimate)
Mercedes-Benz C-Class23.224.5−1.4−2.1 to −0.612,782
Vauxhall Corsa35.937.3−1.4−1.8 to −0.949,345
Audi Q716.617.9−1.4−3.6 to +0.91,051
Renault Kadjar17.018.3−1.4−3.0 to +0.22,140
Audi A426.427.7−1.4−2.3 to −0.59,120
Kia Niro10.111.5−1.4−3.2 to +0.41,115
Renault Clio42.543.9−1.4−2.1 to −0.718,974
Porsche 91111.813.3−1.4−3.5 to +0.6981
Mazda MX-525.126.6−1.4−2.8 to −0.13,826
Nissan X-Trail28.329.8−1.4−2.9 to −0.03,967
Vauxhall Insignia28.329.8−1.5−2.2 to −0.712,652
Peugeot 20648.750.2−1.5−2.8 to −0.15,118
Jaguar XF21.723.2−1.5−2.9 to −0.23,665
Volvo C3037.639.1−1.5−4.3 to +1.31,157
Citroen C3 Aircross11.112.6−1.6−4.6 to +1.5415 (rough estimate)
Volkswagen Golf26.828.4−1.6−2.1 to −1.027,597
Ford Fusion37.939.5−1.6−3.7 to +0.52,099
Mitsubishi Mirage14.916.5−1.6−3.9 to +0.7953
Peugeot 10731.933.5−1.6−2.8 to −0.45,783
Mercedes-Benz SLC9.911.5−1.6−4.9 to +1.7312 (rough estimate)
Jeep Grand Cherokee24.726.3−1.6−5.9 to +2.7385 (rough estimate)
Porsche Cayenne15.116.7−1.6−4.3 to +1.1675
Mitsubishi ASX18.420.0−1.6−3.3 to +0.11,965
BMW 3 Series24.726.3−1.6−2.3 to −1.016,321
Vauxhall Astravan45.647.2−1.6−5.6 to +2.3610
Renault Grand Modus44.446.0−1.6−9.6 to +6.3151 (rough estimate)
Honda Jazz23.625.3−1.7−2.7 to −0.66,657
Hyundai Getz43.945.6−1.7−3.9 to +0.51,978
Volvo S8030.332.0−1.7−7.3 to +4.0254 (rough estimate)
Vauxhall Tigra47.048.6−1.7−5.2 to +1.9773
Hyundai Kona9.711.4−1.7−3.9 to +0.5703
SEAT Arosa42.444.1−1.7−9.0 to +5.6177 (rough estimate)
Vauxhall Adam23.224.9−1.7−3.0 to −0.43,892
Mitsubishi Delica41.743.4−1.7−9.5 to +6.1156 (rough estimate)
Land Rover Discovery Sport15.417.1−1.7−3.3 to −0.22,192
Suzuki Splash30.332.1−1.7−5.1 to +1.7706
Chrysler Jeep Cherokee39.140.9−1.8−8.5 to +5.0202 (rough estimate)
Ford Sierra14.916.7−1.8−7.3 to +3.7161 (rough estimate)
Vauxhall Crossland11.713.5−1.8−3.4 to −0.21,636
Renault Modus48.049.8−1.8−5.1 to +1.5888
Morgan Plus 412.314.1−1.8−7.9 to +4.2114 (rough estimate)
Mercedes-Benz B-Class24.025.9−1.8−3.5 to −0.12,467
Fiat 50028.029.8−1.8−2.6 to −1.114,648
Seat Ibiza31.032.9−1.9−2.8 to −0.99,161
Volkswagen Passat29.030.9−1.9−2.9 to −0.98,049
Citroen C246.548.4−1.9−4.8 to +1.11,101
Citroen DS436.838.7−1.9−6.1 to +2.3506
Renault Scenic43.045.0−1.9−3.6 to −0.33,544
Mercedes-Benz M-Class26.428.4−2.0−4.5 to +0.51,195
Renault Captur17.619.6−2.0−3.0 to −1.05,877
Skoda Octavia22.925.0−2.0−3.0 to −1.17,623
Mazda CX-514.616.6−2.0−3.7 to −0.41,766
Nissan Qashqai26.628.7−2.1−2.7 to −1.520,202
MG MGF35.037.1−2.1−6.5 to +2.3460 (rough estimate)
Hyundai i3030.132.1−2.1−3.3 to −0.85,078
Mercedes-Benz CLK36.338.4−2.1−5.1 to +0.9983
Ford C-MAX26.128.2−2.1−3.5 to −0.83,910
Ford Tourneo Connect18.320.4−2.2−6.3 to +2.0328 (rough estimate)
Suzuki Celerio11.013.1−2.2−4.0 to −0.31,077
BMW i39.511.6−2.2−6.9 to +2.6148 (rough estimate)
Chrysler Ypsilon32.835.0−2.2−7.2 to +2.8345 (rough estimate)
Toyota Hilux29.832.1−2.2−4.3 to −0.21,902
Audi Q26.58.8−2.3−4.0 to −0.5766
Volkswagen Scirocco26.028.3−2.3−4.1 to −0.52,347
Toyota iQ19.622.0−2.3−5.4 to +0.7668
Citroen C125.427.8−2.3−3.4 to −1.37,245
Kia Sedona44.647.0−2.4−6.9 to +2.2455 (rough estimate)
Mercedes-Benz GLE8.911.3−2.4−4.7 to −0.1593
Fiat Grande Punto40.843.1−2.4−6.7 to +2.0488 (rough estimate)
Kia Sportage20.122.5−2.4−3.1 to −1.712,723
Fiat Scudo47.549.9−2.4−6.0 to +1.2754
Volkswagen Transporter30.432.8−2.4−3.3 to −1.511,090
Volvo V9011.814.2−2.4−5.7 to +0.8382 (rough estimate)
Jaguar X-Type40.442.9−2.5−4.8 to −0.11,670
Suzuki Wagon R41.744.2−2.5−6.0 to +1.1746
Land Rover Range Rover Velar12.815.3−2.5−5.9 to +0.9368 (rough estimate)
Peugeot E735.538.0−2.5−10.2 to +5.2152 (rough estimate)
Toyota Urban Cruiser23.626.2−2.5−9.4 to +4.4148 (rough estimate)
Vauxhall Movano35.738.2−2.5−9.4 to +4.4185 (rough estimate)
Citroen Saxo47.249.8−2.5−7.3 to +2.2432 (rough estimate)
Volvo V5041.143.6−2.5−5.1 to −0.01,466
Seat Arona10.613.2−2.5−4.6 to −0.4828
Fiat Qubo30.933.4−2.6−8.0 to +2.8285 (rough estimate)
Vauxhall Meriva34.136.8−2.6−3.8 to −1.56,840
Fiat Panda31.734.3−2.7−4.1 to −1.34,286
Mazda 627.630.3−2.7−4.4 to −0.92,487
Peugeot 40743.446.1−2.7−6.2 to +0.8786
Rover Mini30.333.0−2.7−6.2 to +0.8667
Peugeot 30643.446.1−2.7−7.6 to +2.1403 (rough estimate)
Jaguar F-Pace11.514.2−2.8−4.8 to −0.7907
Toyota RAV423.726.5−2.8−3.9 to −1.65,196
Jaguar XE15.017.8−2.8−4.7 to −0.91,346
Mercedes-Benz CLS22.325.1−2.8−5.6 to +0.0848
Alfa Romeo 14744.447.2−2.8−10.8 to +5.2151 (rough estimate)
Fiat Fiorino35.838.6−2.8−8.1 to +2.5321 (rough estimate)
Citroen Grand C4 Picasso46.649.4−2.8−7.6 to +1.9427 (rough estimate)
Nissan Navara29.932.7−2.8−4.4 to −1.23,197
Volvo S4040.142.9−2.8−6.1 to +0.4888
Vauxhall Vectra45.648.4−2.9−4.5 to −1.23,478
Vauxhall Antara36.939.7−2.9−5.5 to −0.21,305
Volvo S909.011.9−2.9−6.5 to +0.7244 (rough estimate)
Audi A812.515.4−2.9−6.7 to +0.9289 (rough estimate)
Mazda 226.729.6−2.9−4.1 to −1.74,923
Volkswagen Touran31.334.2−2.9−4.8 to −1.02,400
Citroen Xsara48.451.3−2.9−4.6 to −1.33,642
Nissan Pulsar16.219.1−2.9−5.5 to −0.4810
Toyota Aygo20.523.4−3.0−3.8 to −2.210,089
Volkswagen Polo30.133.1−3.0−3.7 to −2.418,557
Mazda CX-38.811.8−3.0−4.9 to −1.2866
Vauxhall Agila32.135.2−3.0−5.0 to −1.12,160
Skoda Karoq6.89.8−3.1−4.6 to −1.5990
Seat Mii16.719.7−3.1−6.1 to −0.1594
BMW M49.612.7−3.1−6.8 to +0.5250 (rough estimate)
Nissan Almera42.045.1−3.1−6.1 to −0.21,083
Nissan Note30.433.5−3.1−4.3 to −2.06,356
Subaru Outback24.027.1−3.1−9.1 to +2.9196 (rough estimate)
Chrysler Crossfire29.833.0−3.2−10.3 to +3.9161 (rough estimate)
Suzuki Jimny28.531.7−3.2−5.7 to −0.71,223
Suzuki Swift25.728.9−3.2−4.5 to −2.04,880
Volkswagen T-Cross6.69.9−3.2−6.3 to −0.2256 (rough estimate)
Porsche Macan4.98.2−3.3−5.6 to −1.0344 (rough estimate)
Skoda Scala7.711.0−3.3−8.5 to +1.8104 (rough estimate)
Volvo XC406.59.9−3.3−4.6 to −2.01,408
Seat Altea37.040.4−3.4−7.1 to +0.4651
Subaru Impreza24.728.0−3.4−6.0 to −0.81,070
Hyundai i1021.424.8−3.4−4.1 to −2.611,995
Peugeot 80751.454.8−3.4−13.0 to +6.2105 (rough estimate)
Kia Soul24.027.5−3.4−5.9 to −1.01,194
Alfa Romeo GT41.544.9−3.4−10.3 to +3.4200 (rough estimate)
Fiat Bravo44.347.8−3.5−8.0 to +1.1458 (rough estimate)
Volvo V4022.025.5−3.5−4.8 to −2.23,909
Hyundai Coupe44.948.4−3.5−7.4 to +0.4632
Mercedes-Benz CLC39.943.4−3.5−9.0 to +2.0308 (rough estimate)
Volkswagen Beetle37.441.0−3.6−5.6 to −1.52,230
MGB18.522.1−3.6−7.6 to +0.5351 (rough estimate)
Smart Fortwo23.727.3−3.6−5.8 to −1.31,383
Honda Insight23.326.8−3.6−11.3 to +4.1116 (rough estimate)
Fiat Tipo19.623.2−3.6−7.4 to +0.2428 (rough estimate)
Toyota Yaris25.629.2−3.6−4.3 to −2.915,758
Vauxhall Combo Life15.919.5−3.6−10.6 to +3.4107 (rough estimate)
Toyota GT8610.113.7−3.6−6.9 to −0.3328 (rough estimate)
Chrysler Voyager45.849.4−3.6−13.1 to +5.9107 (rough estimate)
Volkswagen up!13.817.4−3.6−4.7 to −2.53,972
Lexus LS18.922.5−3.6−10.1 to +2.8143 (rough estimate)
Mercedes-Benz SL13.417.1−3.7−6.4 to −0.9611
Toyota Avensis30.233.8−3.7−5.3 to −2.03,034
Hyundai ix3525.829.5−3.7−5.2 to −2.23,481
Toyota Auris20.924.6−3.7−4.9 to −2.54,398
Kia Ceed28.031.7−3.8−5.0 to −2.55,254
Hyundai Ioniq8.412.2−3.8−6.0 to −1.6607
Nissan 350Z23.527.3−3.8−8.8 to +1.3272 (rough estimate)
Audi A241.545.3−3.8−9.4 to +1.8301 (rough estimate)
Skoda Yeti14.618.4−3.8−5.0 to −2.73,673
Peugeot 10643.146.9−3.8−8.2 to +0.6490 (rough estimate)
Toyota Verso21.925.7−3.9−6.7 to −1.0814
Jaguar XK19.423.3−3.9−6.7 to −1.1752
Kia Rio25.829.7−3.9−5.2 to −2.74,777
Citroen Relay32.836.7−3.9−8.0 to +0.1525
Mitsubishi Eclipse8.312.2−3.9−7.1 to −0.8301 (rough estimate)
Skoda Fabia25.329.3−3.9−4.8 to −3.110,397
Toyota MR231.735.7−3.9−7.4 to −0.5719
Jaguar S-Type33.837.8−4.0−7.9 to −0.0559
Perodua Myvi25.229.2−4.0−8.7 to +0.7337 (rough estimate)
Peugeot 50823.627.6−4.0−7.3 to −0.7652
Suzuki Alto28.032.0−4.0−5.9 to −2.22,352
Smart Forfour20.824.8−4.1−7.4 to −0.8583
Kia Carens32.636.7−4.1−7.3 to −0.9823
Volvo XC9025.529.6−4.1−6.1 to −2.11,916
SEAT Toledo26.430.7−4.2−10.0 to +1.5227 (rough estimate)
Daewoo Matiz51.555.7−4.2−11.9 to +3.4165 (rough estimate)
Peugeot Boxer22.827.0−4.2−5.8 to −2.72,720
Dacia Duster20.224.5−4.3−6.0 to −2.52,013
Kia Venga20.224.4−4.3−6.1 to −2.51,984
Citroen C3 Picasso19.724.0−4.3−9.5 to +0.9228 (rough estimate)
Nissan Figaro35.740.0−4.3−11.9 to +3.3154 (rough estimate)
Volkswagen Jetta29.834.1−4.3−8.0 to −0.7601
Fiat Ducato22.727.1−4.4−5.8 to −3.03,480
Volvo XC6014.819.2−4.4−5.6 to −3.23,262
Suzuki Grand Vitara32.637.1−4.5−6.7 to −2.21,687
Lotus Elise11.616.0−4.5−8.8 to −0.2216 (rough estimate)
Toyota Corolla28.933.4−4.5−6.1 to −2.93,048
Volvo S6026.130.6−4.5−7.4 to −1.6874
Mitsubishi Lancer29.634.2−4.5−8.0 to −1.0655
Hyundai i2020.525.0−4.5−5.6 to −3.55,813
Volkswagen Arteon8.413.0−4.6−9.6 to +0.4119 (rough estimate)
Chrysler PT43.948.5−4.7−12.5 to +3.2155 (rough estimate)
Kia Stonic5.810.5−4.7−6.3 to −3.1818
TVR Chimaera11.015.8−4.8−8.3 to −1.3318 (rough estimate)
Honda FR-V38.743.6−4.9−11.8 to +2.1191 (rough estimate)
Skoda Citigo12.517.4−4.9−6.2 to −3.62,432
Volvo V7032.737.6−4.9−7.3 to −2.61,545
Honda Accord34.839.7−4.9−7.7 to −2.11,125
Nissan Micra31.736.7−5.0−5.8 to −4.111,809
Skoda Kodiaq5.310.3−5.0−7.0 to −3.0488 (rough estimate)
Chevrolet Spark38.543.6−5.0−7.7 to −2.41,328
Nissan Primera41.346.4−5.1−11.1 to +1.0259 (rough estimate)
Honda Integra15.620.7−5.1−12.0 to +1.8109 (rough estimate)
Kia XCeed7.312.4−5.1−8.0 to −2.3330 (rough estimate)
Dacia Sandero22.727.8−5.2−6.7 to −3.72,983
Land Rover Defender27.933.0−5.2−6.7 to −3.73,562
Daihatsu Charade36.341.5−5.2−14.6 to +4.2102 (rough estimate)
Fiat Seicento43.048.3−5.2−13.2 to +2.7151 (rough estimate)
Peugeot 100735.741.0−5.3−12.3 to +1.7182 (rough estimate)
Toyota Vellfire10.115.5−5.4−10.7 to −0.1129 (rough estimate)
Renault Twingo28.734.2−5.5−8.1 to −2.91,174
Mazda 325.431.1−5.7−7.1 to −4.33,782
Rover 21434.840.6−5.7−14.6 to +3.2112 (rough estimate)
LDV Maxus41.547.2−5.7−12.7 to +1.2193 (rough estimate)
Volkswagen Bora38.644.4−5.8−11.3 to −0.3306 (rough estimate)
Citroen C4 Picasso14.820.6−5.8−10.9 to −0.7189 (rough estimate)
Toyota Prius16.121.9−5.8−7.3 to −4.42,411
Hyundai Amica35.941.8−5.9−9.6 to −2.2657
Mitsubishi Colt37.042.9−5.9−8.3 to −3.61,605
Morgan 4/410.116.1−5.9−10.7 to −1.2158 (rough estimate)
Volkswagen Fox39.545.5−5.9−8.7 to −3.21,207
Kia Picanto23.229.1−5.9−6.9 to −5.08,436
Volvo XC7023.829.8−6.0−9.6 to −2.4537
Vauxhall Signum41.147.2−6.0−12.8 to +0.7209 (rough estimate)
Toyota Starlet29.635.7−6.1−13.4 to +1.2152 (rough estimate)
Nissan Terrano41.147.3−6.2−13.7 to +1.3168 (rough estimate)
Toyota Celica34.640.8−6.2−9.9 to −2.6651
Chevrolet Matiz42.148.4−6.3−9.2 to −3.41,147
Nissan Pixo25.732.0−6.3−10.1 to −2.6521
Isuzu Rodeo38.344.7−6.3−12.9 to +0.2214 (rough estimate)
Skoda Roomster24.331.0−6.7−9.5 to −3.9905
Mazda B250036.943.6−6.7−16.1 to +2.6103 (rough estimate)
Dacia Logan19.426.5−7.1−10.6 to −3.6484 (rough estimate)
Volkswagen Caravelle28.635.8−7.1−11.1 to −3.1496 (rough estimate)
Honda S200013.220.6−7.4−11.8 to −3.0228 (rough estimate)
Hyundai i80029.236.9−7.7−13.9 to −1.5209 (rough estimate)
Talbot Express40.248.0−7.8−13.1 to −2.5333 (rough estimate)
Daihatsu Sirion27.235.2−8.0−12.7 to −3.3349 (rough estimate)
Mercedes-Benz X-Class11.919.9−8.0−14.3 to −1.6101 (rough estimate)
Volkswagen Lupo33.741.7−8.0−12.7 to −3.3392 (rough estimate)
Renault Master25.934.1−8.2−11.2 to −5.2819
Toyota Estima15.924.1−8.2−11.5 to −4.9471 (rough estimate)
Honda Stepwagon18.727.0−8.3−15.7 to −0.8107 (rough estimate)
Renault Zoe14.823.3−8.6−14.3 to −2.9149 (rough estimate)
Renault Wind32.541.1−8.6−17.0 to −0.2120 (rough estimate)
Mazda Bongo37.045.6−8.6−13.2 to −4.0430 (rough estimate)
Hyundai Accent38.447.2−8.8−15.2 to −2.5229 (rough estimate)
Citroen C-Crosser33.342.2−8.9−17.3 to −0.4120 (rough estimate)
Smart City-Coupe32.942.0−9.0−14.9 to −3.2249 (rough estimate)
Chevrolet Kalos44.253.2−9.0−14.6 to −3.4308 (rough estimate)
Toyota Alphard17.326.5−9.2−12.3 to −6.1584
Mitsubishi Pajero25.736.1−10.4−16.3 to −4.5214 (rough estimate)
Iveco Daily24.635.3−10.8−16.2 to −5.4248 (rough estimate)
Subaru Legacy26.337.6−11.3−16.2 to −6.5316 (rough estimate)
Vauxhall Frontera30.542.1−11.6−18.7 to −4.4164 (rough estimate)
Chrysler 300C25.637.5−11.9−19.3 to −4.6137 (rough estimate)
Peugeot Rifter5.818.2−12.4−16.6 to −8.1120 (rough estimate)
Alfa Romeo 15930.443.7−13.2−19.4 to −7.1220 (rough estimate)
Suzuki Carry30.945.0−14.0−20.8 to −7.3181 (rough estimate)
Nissan Elgrand17.032.3−15.4−17.2 to −13.51,675

Source: DVSA MOT bulk data (OGL v3.0) · Window: 2019–2024 · n = 1,243,382 (initial tests in DY) · Method: postcode area of the testing station; the area's first-time failure share against the same model's tests elsewhere in Britain, difference of two proportions with a 95% interval; named only when the interval excludes zero and the gap is at least 3 points; not age-adjusted · Updated: 30 Sep 2026 · Release: dvsa-2024-v2 · CSV