Which BMW models fail their MOT less for their age?

BMW models fail their MOT less often than other cars of the same age.

of MOTs on the 25 BMW models we cover failed at the first attempt in 2024
21.7%of MOTs on the 25 BMW models we cover failed at the first attempt in 2024

Average for cars of the same age: 27.8%

Of BMW models with 10,000 or more tests, the BMW M3 fails least for its age.

Data: DVSA MOT results · 2024 · 1,733,065 tests

Check a BMW by registration

Choose your BMW model

The brand figure above always covers all published models; choosing a model opens its own results.

Popular BMW models

  • BMW 3 Series · car · index 80.7 (100 = normal for age)
  • BMW 1 Series · car · index 85.0 (100 = normal for age)
  • BMW 5 Series · car · index 71.8 (100 = normal for age)
  • BMW X1 · car · index 75.1 (100 = normal for age)
  • BMW 4 Series · car · index 75.8 (100 = normal for age)

Check this car by registration

For example, AB12 CDE

Before you submit. Enter a UK registration to compare this vehicle with similar cars: statistical information, not vehicle condition advice. It goes to the DVSA MOT History API, never into URLs or analytics, and any cache expires within 15 minutes. MOT history is free on GOV.UK and we do not sell it; read how we use your data.

Free to use. Independent site. Not affiliated with DVSA, DVLA or GOV.UK.

Full catalogue and evidence

Download this page’s numbers (CSV) · How to cite

In 2024, 82.1% of MOTs on the 25 BMW models published here passed (78.3% first time, 3.9% after a fix at the test centre), from 1,733,065 first tests. Allowing for age (not mileage), these BMW models fail 22% less often than normal: brand MOT Risk Index 78.1 (95% CI 77.9–78.3; 100 = normal). Among BMW models with at least 10,000 first tests, the BMW M3 has the lowest index (39.8) and the BMW X2 the highest (99.7, close to normal). On raw pass rates, the BMW i3 comes first instead, because the models' fleets differ in age.

Which BMW models fail least and most for their age?

Of the 25 BMW models, 22 fail less often than normal for their age, 1 more often, and 2 cannot be told apart from normal because their 95% intervals include 100.

BMW models by MOT Risk Index, lowest first (2024)
ModelTypeMOT pass rate, %Passed first time, %MOT Risk Index95% intervalFirst tests
BMW M5car89.287.336.733.8–39.83,898
BMW M3car88.786.139.838.3–41.415,820
BMW M6car88.787.142.236.6–48.61,281
BMW M8car95.294.244.129.9–64.5415
BMW I8car90.789.049.543.9–55.72,175
BMW 7 Seriescar86.083.459.057.1–60.919,187
BMW M2car89.388.460.955.7–66.53,719
BMW M4car88.687.363.961.0–66.912,459
BMW Z4car80.577.264.763.5–66.035,286
BMW 6 Seriescar82.079.565.463.7–67.122,568
BMW X6car85.082.667.365.0–69.615,622
BMW 5 Seriescar82.479.271.871.2–72.4211,217
BMW i3car89.887.172.570.2–75.023,610
BMW X5car82.379.273.572.6–74.591,002
BMW X1car85.782.875.174.1–76.1107,276
BMW 4 Seriescar85.883.875.874.8–76.9106,629
BMW X4car87.485.079.776.9–82.617,419
BMW 3 Seriescar79.775.180.780.4–81.1498,596
BMW X3car83.679.981.780.7–82.7104,772
BMW Z3car73.968.783.681.3–85.811,668
BMW 1 Seriescar81.076.185.084.5–85.5398,575
BMW 8 Seriescar86.585.189.984.5–95.65,789
BMW X2car88.185.299.796.3–103.119,091
BMW IX3car88.687.2105.696.2–115.73,077
BMW X7car86.584.8113.9102.3–126.51,914

Source: DVSA MOT bulk data · Window: 2024 · n = 1,733,065 (initial tests) · Method: MOT Risk Index = observed first-time failures ÷ failures expected for the same age profile × 100; brand index sums both over the 25 models · Updated: 25 Sep 2026 · Release: dvsa-2024-v2 · CSV

dot · BMW · MOT Risk Index · 78.1 vs 100 = normal · 2024
Published BMW models: age-adjusted first-time MOT failure, with 95% intervals. Cars and commercial vehicles are identified in the table; 100 = normal for age. BMW 78.1. BMW M3: 39.8; BMW 7 Series: 59.0; BMW Z4: 64.7; BMW 6 Series: 65.4; BMW 5 Series: 71.8; BMW i3: 72.5; BMW X5: 73.5; BMW X1: 75.1; BMW 4 Series: 75.8; BMW 3 Series: 80.7; BMW X3: 81.7; BMW 1 Series: 85.0; BMW X2: 99.7. Axis from 30 to 110.

Where are BMW models worse than other cars of the same age?

Allowing for age, BMW models fail on tyres more than other cars of the same age: 10.2 failures per 100 tests against 8.7 expected (1.5 more; 95% interval 1.47 to 1.51).

BMW: failures per 100 tests by group against the same-age expectation (2019–2024)
Failure groupBMW, per 100 testsExpected for the same ageDifference95% intervalMost common failure on (models)
Tyres10.28.7+1.51.47 to 1.5116 of 25
Road Wheels1.10.4+0.70.72 to 0.740 of 25
Identification of the vehicle0.60.4+0.20.16 to 0.170 of 25
Seat belts and supplementary restraint systems1.01.1-0.1-0.10 to -0.090 of 25
Visibility7.07.8-0.8-0.78 to -0.750 of 25
Noise, emissions and leaks2.33.6-1.3-1.35 to -1.330 of 25
Steering0.92.8-1.8-1.83 to -1.820 of 25
Brakes9.111.2-2.1-2.08 to -2.042 of 25
Body, chassis, structure1.85.4-3.5-3.54 to -3.520 of 25
Suspension9.114.5-5.4-5.45 to -5.423 of 25
Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment10.116.8-6.7-6.73 to -6.694 of 25

Source: DVSA MOT bulk data · Window: 2019–2024 · n = 9,776,550 (initial tests of the 25 models) · Method: failure items per 100 tests against the rate expected for the same age and kind of vehicle; interval from the count of failures (Poisson); a group is named only when its interval is wholly above zero and it is at least 5% above the expected rate · Updated: 25 Sep 2026 · Release: dvsa-2024-v2 · CSV

How to cite this page

MOT Risk Index (2026). BMW MOT statistics by model 2024 (data release dvsa-2024-v2; full dataset motriskindex-families-2024-v5, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.22975051), updated 25 September 2026. motriskindex.co.uk/cars/brand/bmw/

How the MOT Risk Index and every figure on this page are calculated: methodology.

Report an error

What is wrong on this page? One tap sends the category only, no text and nothing about you.