Does the Smart City have more brake problems than other cars its age?

Smart Citys do have brake problems recorded, but less often than other cars their age.

per 100 tests
15.58 per 100 testsdefects recorded at first MOT tests

Expected for cars of the same age: 23.66 per 100 tests

One test can record several defects, so this is not the share of Smart Citys.

Data: DVSA MOT results · 2019–2024 · 6,619 tests

Check a Smart City by registration

How often do brake advisories on Smart Citys turn into fails?

14.1% of brake advisories on Smart Citys turned into brake fails at the next MOT.

Typically, the next MOT came 12 months and 2,029 miles later.

Based on 1,366 advisories, each followed to the car's next MOT, 2019–2024. This counts advisories, not cars.

Which brake problem is recorded most on the Smart City?

Brake pipe rusted or damaged: recorded 196 times in 2019–2024, or 2.96 per 100 tests.

A metal brake pipe is badly rusted or damaged and could leak brake fluid, which fails the MOT.

What to check: Look along the underside at the metal brake pipes for flaking rust, and ask whether they were renewed.

Check a Smart City by registration

For example, AB12 CDE

Before you submit. Enter a UK registration to compare this vehicle with similar cars: statistical information, not vehicle condition advice. It goes to the DVSA MOT History API, never into URLs or analytics, and any cache expires within 15 minutes. MOT history is free on GOV.UK and we do not sell it; read how we use your data.

Free to use. Independent site. Not affiliated with DVSA, DVLA or GOV.UK.

Which brake problems should I check for on a used Smart City?

The brake defects recorded most often on Smart Citys, 2019–2024, per 100 tests.

  • Brake pipe rusted or damaged2.96
    Major

    What to check: Look along the underside at the metal brake pipes for flaking rust, and ask whether they were renewed.

  • Brake hose cracked or chafed1.98
    Major

    What to check: Turn the steering to full lock and check the rubber brake hoses behind the front wheels for cracks or rubbing.

  • Uneven braking side to side1.31
    Major

    What to check: Brake firmly on a quiet straight road and check the car stops in a straight line.

  • ABS or brake warning light on1.09
    Major

    What to check: Check the ABS light goes out after start-up and stays out on the test drive.

  • Brake dragging when released1.03
    Major

    What to check: Check the car rolls freely when coasting and does not pull to one side.

One test can record several defects, so this is not the share of Smart Citys.

Each tip applies only if the car you are looking at has that fault in its own MOT history.

All DVSA descriptions in this group (5)
Smart City: brake defects recorded at MOTs, 2019–2024, 30 or more each
DVSA descriptionIn plain wordsRecordedPer 100 tests
Brake pipe damaged or excessively corrodedBrake pipe rusted or damaged1962.96
A flexible brake hose excessively damaged, deteriorated, chafed, twisted or stretched Brake hose cracked or chafed1311.98
Brakes imbalance across an axle such that the braking effort from any wheel is less than 70% of the maximum effort recorded from the other wheel on the same axle.Uneven braking side to side871.31
Warning device shows system malfunctionABS or brake warning light on721.09
Significant brake effort recorded with no brake applied indicating a binding brakeBrake dragging when released681.03

Download these figures (CSV)

How are these figures calculated?

Defects are counted at first MOT tests, 2019–2024. The expected rate is for cars with the same mix of ages.

The comparison uses 6,619 initial tests. The difference is −8.08 defects per 100 tests (95% interval −9.26 to −6.91).

Full methodology

How to cite these figures

Download the full dataset (CSV) · All models on brakes