Is a 2004 Smart City a good buy? What its MOT record shows

2004 Smart Citys fail their MOT about as often as other Smart Citys at the same age.

Failed at the first attempt
41.4%failed at the first attempt, 2019–2024

Other Smart Citys at the same ages: 43.5%

This is a rough estimate from a smaller sample.

Data: DVSA MOT results · 2019–2024 · 905 tests

Year means the year the car was first registered, as DVSA records it. It may differ from the year it was built.

Check a 2004 Smart City by registration

What fails most on a 2004 Smart City?

On 2004 Smart Citys, lights and electrical problems are the most common failure: 49.40 per 100 tests.

Across all years of the Smart City, the figure is 46.40.

These counts are not adjusted for age: 2004 cars were 15 to 20 years old when tested.

  • lamps, reflectors and electrics49.40
  • suspension20.30
  • brakes18.20
  • visibility13.80
  • noise, emissions and leaks13.00

One test can record several defects, so this is not the share of Smart Citys.

Check a 2004 Smart City by registration

For example, AB12 CDE

Before you submit. Enter a UK registration to compare this vehicle with similar cars: statistical information, not vehicle condition advice. It goes to the DVSA MOT History API, never into URLs or analytics, and any cache expires within 15 minutes. MOT history is free on GOV.UK and we do not sell it; read how we use your data.

Free to use. Independent site. Not affiliated with DVSA, DVLA or GOV.UK.

Rank among 4 years of the Smart City
1, where 1 fails least for its age
Ages at their MOTs
15 to 20 years old
MOTs in 2024
244
Typical mileage at the 2024 MOT
70,622 miles

How does a 2004 Smart City compare at each age?

Smart Citys first registered in 2004 were tested at ages 15 to 20. Each point compares them with other Smart Citys of that age.

line · Smart City built 2004 · first-time MOT failure share by age · built 2004 41.3% vs model normal 44.9% at age 15 · 2019–2024
Built 2004 against Smart City normal for the age, 2019–2024. Vertical axis: 0% to 50%.
  • Age 15: 41.3% failed, against 44.9% for other Smart Citys (rough estimate)
  • Age 16: 41.6% failed, against 41.9% for other Smart Citys (rough estimate)
  • Age 17: 45.4% failed (rough estimate)
  • Age 18: 44.6% failed (rough estimate)
  • Age 19: 36.7% failed (rough estimate)
  • Age 20: 39.8% failed (rough estimate)
Figures by age
2004 Smart City: failures by age, 2019–2024
AgeTestsFailed first timeOther Smart Citys at that age
1548941.3%44.9%
1641641.6%41.9%
1738345.4%not available
1833244.6%not available
1929436.7%not available
2024439.8%not available
Download these figures (CSV)

How does 2004 compare with other Smart City years?

Among 4 years of the Smart City with figures, 2004 ranks 1, where 1 fails least for its age.

Years without published figures

Year means the year the car was first registered, as DVSA records it. It may differ from the year it was built.

How to cite this page

MOT Risk Index (2026). Smart City 2004 MOT statistics (data release dvsa-2024-v2; full dataset motriskindex-families-2024-v5, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.22975051), updated 30 September 2026. motriskindex.co.uk/cars/smart-city-review-f7c5aa62/2004/

How are these figures calculated?

Each year is compared with other Smart Citys at the same ages, allowing for each test year.

Age, test year and registration year are tied together. The overall failure level of each test year is taken as observed.

Full methodology

How to cite these figures