Does the BMW X1 fail the MOT on brakes more than it should?

The BMW X1 records 4.22 brakes failure items per 100 initial MOT tests (2019–2024), against 6.57 expected for a car of the same age mix: less than expected for its class and age (−2.35, 95% interval −2.42 to −2.28). It ranks 471 of 712 models on brakes (1 = most failures above expected).

Data release dvsa-2024-v2 (24 Sep 2026) · page updated 30 Sep 2026 · all models on brakes · check a BMW X1 by registration

What exactly fails on brakes?

The most frequent DVSA defect wording in this group on the BMW X1 is “a brake lining or pad worn below 1.5mm”, recorded 6,426 times in 2019–2024.

BMW X1: most frequent brakes defect wordings, 2019–2024 (30+ items each)
DVSA defect wording	Items	Per 100 tests
a brake lining or pad worn below 1.5mm	6,426	1.28
Parking brake efficiency below minimum requirement	2,360	0.47
Brake lining or pad worn down to wear indicator	2,125	0.42
Significant brake effort recorded with no brake applied indicating a binding brake	1,605	0.32
Brake disc or drum significantly and obviously worn	1,034	0.21

Source: DVSA MOT bulk data (OGL v3.0) · Window: 2019–2024 · n = 503,065 (initial tests) · Method: failure items (major and minor) grouped by DVSA's defect tree; wordings with 30+ items · Updated: 30 Sep 2026 · Release: dvsa-2024-v2 · CSV

If a BMW X1 gets a brakes advisory, how often does it fail next time?

7.2% of BMW X1 MOTs with a brakes advisory were followed by a fail in the same group at the next MOT, typically 12 months and 7,024 miles later (44,239 advisories followed).

Source: DVSA MOT bulk data (OGL v3.0) · Window: 2019–2024 · n = 44,239 (advisories followed) · Method: the same vehicles followed to their next ordinary MOT · Updated: 30 Sep 2026 · Release: dvsa-2024-v2 · CSV

Does the BMW X1 fail the MOT on brakes more than it should?

What exactly fails on brakes?

If a BMW X1 gets a brakes advisory, how often does it fail next time?

Related pages

Other pages for this model