Smart Forfour — MOT statistics 2024
The Smart Forfour failed 25.58% of 21,386 first MOT attempts in 2024 ("first-time", excluding retests). Adjusted for the age of the fleet, its initial-failure ratio is 118.2 (100 = expected for its age profile). This car fails its MOT about 18% more often than expected for its age.
Age-adjusted peer: Nissan Qashqai (index 118.2) — the two published results are 0.0 index points apart.
Check this car by registration
Smart Forfour common problems: what actually fails the MOT
Visibility stands out at 7.8 per 100 tests, against 5.5 per 100 tests across UK vehicles of the same ages.
higher bar = fails more oftenrate per 100 tests
family vs national — matched to UK vehicles of the same ages — top component groups, per 100 tests. Legend: This family · National avg. Combined labels: family / national average. A gap here reflects how these vehicles are driven, used and maintained as well as how they were built — an MOT defect is a test outcome, not a breakdown.
Component-group comparison table
Each ratio carries a 95% interval. With 6 groups compared here, roughly one apparent difference in twenty is chance alone.
| Group | This family | Cases behind it | UK, same ages | Family / national |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tyres | 9.2 | 10,262 | 7.3 | 1.27×1.24–1.29 |
| Visibility | 7.8 | 8,767 | 5.5 | 1.42×1.40–1.46 |
| Suspension | 4.0 | 4,488 | 4.2 | 0.96×0.94–0.99 |
| Lamps & electrical | 4.0 | 4,415 | 5.1 | 0.78×0.75–0.79 |
| Brakes | 3.8 | 4,226 | 4.8 | 0.80×0.77–0.82 |
| Emissions & leaks | 3.2 | 3,610 | 1.1 | 2.91×2.84–3.03 |
| What failed | per 100 tests (this family) | per 100 tests (UK average) | ratio family / UK | What to check |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wiper missing or not clearing the screenWiper blade missing or obviously not clearing the windscreen | 3.67 | 2.22 | 1.65× | Wet the screen and run the wipers: they should clear the glass in front of the driver without streaks or juddering. |
| Fuel mixture reading out of rangeLambda coefficient outside the default limits or the range specified by the manufacturer | 1.28 | 0.53 | 2.42× | Ask whether an oxygen sensor or the catalytic converter was replaced, and check the engine warning light is out. |
| Tyre tread below the legal limitTyre tread depth not in accordance with the requirements | 4.06 | 3.59 | 1.13× | Check the tread across every tyre with a gauge; wear on one edge points to a tracking fault. |
| Wiper blade wornWiper blade defective | 1.56 | 1.26 | 1.24× | Check the rubber edge of each wiper blade for splits and run the wipers on a wet screen. |
| Tyre cords showing or damagedA tyre cords visible or damaged | 1.61 | 1.63 | 0.99× | Check the inner edges of the front tyres, where cords show first, and ask whether the alignment was checked. |
| Tyre badly cut or damagedA tyre seriously damaged | 2.26 | 2.54 | 0.89× | Check both sidewalls of every tyre, including the inner side, for cuts, bulges and tears. |
| Brake pads or shoes dangerously thina brake lining or pad worn below 1.5mm | 1.82 | 2.15 | 0.85× | Look through the wheels at the pads and discs, listen for grinding, and ask when they were last replaced. |
| Brake light not workingStop lamp missing, inoperative or in the case of a multiple light source more than 1/2 not functioning | 1.13 | 1.50 | 0.75× | Have someone watch all the brake lights, including the high-level one, while you press the pedal. |
| Windscreen or window damagedWindscreen or window damaged or seriously discoloured but not adversely affecting driver's view | 1.13 | 2.36 | 0.48× | Look for chips and cracks across the windscreen: chips spread, and larger damage in front of the driver fails. |
| Worn suspension bush or jointA suspension pin, bush or joint excessively worn | 2.45 | 4.87 | 0.50× | Listen for knocks over speed bumps, feel for the car wandering under braking, and ask which part was replaced. |
Named defects ranked by how much more often they appear than the national average — not by raw rate.
Smart Forfour MOT advisories: what gets flagged
Tyres are highest at 42.7 per 100 tests; Identification is lowest at 0.7 per 100 tests — the gap is 42.0 per 100 tests.
higher bar = flagged more oftenadvisory items per 100 initial tests
Advisory rates table
| Group | Advisories per 100 |
|---|---|
| Tyres | 42.7 |
| Brakes | 21.2 |
| Non-component advisories | 4.8 |
| Suspension | 3.9 |
| Emissions & leaks | 0.9 |
| Identification | 0.7 |
Advisories are wear the tester noted but didn't fail — what will need money soon.
Tyres, brakes and suspension: Smart Forfour against cars of the same age
| Age | Part | Smart Forfour | Same age, petrol and diesel | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 years | Tyres | 4.03 | 4.17 | -0.14 |
| 3 years | Brakes | 1.41 | 1.77 | -0.36 |
| 3 years | Suspension | 0.26 | 0.63 | -0.37 |
| 4 years | Tyres | 5.39 | 4.54 | 0.85 |
| 4 years | Brakes | 2.41 | 2.43 | -0.02 |
| 4 years | Suspension | 1.08 | 1.21 | -0.13 |
| 5 years | Tyres | 6.5 | 5.06 | 1.44 |
| 5 years | Brakes | 2.75 | 3.09 | -0.34 |
| 5 years | Suspension | 1.89 | 2.19 | -0.30 |
| 6 years | Tyres | 6.97 | 5.54 | 1.43 |
| 6 years | Brakes | 3.12 | 3.81 | -0.69 |
| 6 years | Suspension | 3.06 | 3.72 | -0.66 |
| 7 years | Tyres | 7.82 | 5.95 | 1.87 |
| 7 years | Brakes | 3.15 | 4.55 | -1.40 |
| 7 years | Suspension | 5.32 | 5.68 | -0.36 |
| 8 years | Tyres | 7.65 | 6.31 | 1.34 |
| 8 years | Brakes | 3.38 | 5.38 | -2.00 |
| 8 years | Suspension | 8.28 | 7.78 | 0.50 |
Failing items per 100 initial tests, 2019-2024. The comparison group is every petrol or diesel car tested at the same age, so weight and drivetrain show up rather than fleet age.
If a car like this fails, does it fail again?
A failure rate does not say whether a failure is a one-off or the start of something. This follows the same vehicles into their next ordinary MOT a year later — retests after a repair are excluded, because they follow a failure by definition. 2019-2024.
| After this year's test | Fails next year | Vehicles followed |
|---|---|---|
| It failed | 27.0% | 5,429 |
| It passed | 20.2% | 69,098 |
A failed test raises next year's chance of failing again by 6.8 percentage points. The failure most likely to come back is lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment — 33.8% of those vehicles fail again next year. Some of this is the vehicle and some is the owner: a car that was let go once tends to be let go again. One caveat: a car that fails may be sold or scrapped rather than tested again, so these figures describe the vehicles that came back.
Adjusted for how much these are actually driven
The headline index adjusts for the fleet's age. Wear, though, follows mileage: a three-year-old taxi and a three-year-old garage queen sit in the same age band. These two rows compare every car with vehicles of the same age, and then with vehicles of the same age and the same annual mileage, 2019-2024, on 110,112 tests. Both stand on the six-year corpus so they are measured on identical data — compare them with each other, not with the headline index above, which is measured on 2024 alone.
| Standardised for | Index | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| Age only | 111.0 | fails more often than expected |
| Age and annual mileage | 133.5 | fails more often than vehicles driven as much |
| Share doing under 3,000 miles a year | 15.5% | a normal spread of use |
Mileage matters here: matching on how much these are driven moves the figure by 22.5 points — this fleet is driven less than the vehicles it is measured against, so the age-only view flatters it — but it does not change which side of normal the car sits on. One limit to keep in mind: mileage is partly a result of how often a car breaks down — one that spends weeks in the workshop covers fewer miles — so the mileage-matched figure can understate a real weakness. Tests with no usable odometer reading are left out of it.
How the Smart Forfour compares with cars of its own age and size
Not against the whole fleet — against cars of the same size class tested at the same age, 2019-2024.
| Age | Smart Forfour | Same class, same age | Difference | Tests |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 years | 11.98% | 10.86% | +1.13 pp | 17,191 |
| 4 years | 18.19% | 13.78% | +4.41 pp | 21,468 |
| 5 years | 19.26% | 17.34% | +1.92 pp | 21,214 |
| 6 years | 21.45% | 20.62% | +0.83 pp | 19,491 |
| 7 years | 25.02% | 23.49% | +1.53 pp | 15,634 |
| 8 years | 28.93% | 26.74% | +2.19 pp | 10,864 |
| 9 years | 32.39% | 30.33% | +2.05 pp | 5,490 |
Raw first-time failure rates within each age, so fleet age cannot flatter either side. A positive difference means this model fails more often than its own class at that age.
How does the Smart Forfour perform as it gets older?
The Forfour at age 9 stands out at 32.4%, against 26.5% for all vehicles of the same age.
higher = larger sharecompare shares in percentage points
Chart axes: car age, years · failure-rate scale 0–35%.
Takeaway: solid line: this family; dashed: all cars; from about age 5 it stays above the national age curve.
Data table
| Age (years) | Smart Forfour | Tests | All vehicles | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | 18.5% | 1,952 | 15.1% | +3.4 pp |
| 6 | 18.8% | 3,845 | 17.5% | +1.3 pp |
| 7 | 23.2% | 4,777 | 20.2% | +3.1 pp |
| 8 | 28.2% | 5,315 | 23.3% | +4.8 pp |
| 9 | 32.4% | 5,490 | 26.5% | +5.9 pp |
Is a Smart Forfour ULEZ compliant?
The share of classifiable 2024 Smart Forfour MOT tests likely ULEZ compliant by first-registration date is 100.0%.
Based on 21,385 classifiable initial MOT tests. This describes the tested fleet, not a specific car. MOT data do not record Euro class, so likely compliance is inferred from fuel and first-registration date. For the only authoritative answer, check the registration with TfL's official ULEZ checker.
higher = larger share likely compliantinferred from fuel and first-registration date; not a recorded Euro class
| Vehicle age at test | Likely ULEZ-compliant share | Tests |
|---|---|---|
| Under 3 years | Suppressed — sample below publication threshold Check a registration with TfL | n = 0 |
| 3–5 years | 100.0% Check a registration with TfL | n = 1,959 |
| 6–7 years | 100.0% Check a registration with TfL | n = 8,622 |
| 8 years | 100.0% Check a registration with TfL | n = 5,314 |
| 9 years | 100.0% Check a registration with TfL | n = 5,490 |
| 10–14 years | Suppressed — sample below publication threshold Check a registration with TfL | n = 0 |
| 15–17 years | Suppressed — sample below publication threshold Check a registration with TfL | n = 0 |
| 18 years | Suppressed — sample below publication threshold Check a registration with TfL | n = 0 |
| 19 years | Suppressed — sample below publication threshold Check a registration with TfL | n = 0 |
| 20+ years | Suppressed — sample below publication threshold Check a registration with TfL | n = 0 |
Smart Forfour MOT failure rate by fuel
Fuel split table
| Fuel | Tests | % failing |
|---|---|---|
| Petrol | 21,004 | 25.70% |
Samples: n=21k.
How dangerous are Smart Forfour MOT failures?
Major defects are well below the reference at 20.3 per 100 tests, against 52.8 per 100 tests nationally.
higher bar = fails more oftenrate per 100 tests
Severity table
| Severity | This family /100 | National /100 | Family / national |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minor | 4.07 | 14.22 | 0.29× |
| Major | 20.31 | 52.75 | 0.39× |
| Dangerous | 9.18 | 11.15 | 0.82× |
Chart values: Minor 4.1 · Major 20.3 · Dangerous 9.2.
Per 100 tests on this family. National average: Minor 14.2 · Major 52.8 · Dangerous 11.2 per 100.
Does the month of a Smart Forfour MOT matter?
Dec is highest at 22.5%; Mar is lowest at 18.8% — the gap is 3.7 percentage points.
higher = larger sharecompare shares in percentage points
Chart scale: 17%–33%.
bars: Smart Forfour · dashed: all class-4 cars
Month-by-month table
| Month | Smart Forfour tests | Smart Forfour failing | All vehicles failing | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan | 9,027 | 21.59% | 31.12% | -9.5 pp |
| Feb | 7,759 | 20.23% | 29.99% | -9.8 pp |
| Mar | 10,568 | 18.75% | 28.26% | -9.5 pp |
| Apr | 6,867 | 19.44% | 29.78% | -10.3 pp |
| May | 7,754 | 18.84% | 28.79% | -9.9 pp |
| Jun | 9,067 | 20.01% | 28.15% | -8.1 pp |
| Jul | 9,500 | 20.92% | 29.33% | -8.4 pp |
| Aug | 9,227 | 21.92% | 29.2% | -7.3 pp |
| Sep | 12,901 | 20.2% | 28.19% | -8.0 pp |
| Oct | 11,757 | 21.14% | 30.34% | -9.2 pp |
| Nov | 9,915 | 22.46% | 30.58% | -8.1 pp |
| Dec | 7,381 | 22.46% | 29.33% | -6.9 pp |
The highest and lowest monthly failure rates for the Smart Forfour differ by 3.7 percentage points.
Across the national sample, 18.9% of initial test records were for vehicles first registered in March and 17.1% for vehicles first registered in September. Britain introduces new registration plates in those months. The table shows how many Smart Forfourtests took place in each month and what percentage failed.
Smart Forfour average mileage by age
At age 8, the middle half of Forfours runs from 30,025 miles to 56,238 miles, against 41,808 miles as the median.
further right = more milesmedian is the typical car; band is p25–p75
Chart axes: car age, years · odometer scale 0–66k mi.
Does high mileage mean more Smart Forfour MOT failures at the same age?
Within the same age group, split by odometer (2024 MOTs), so this separates wear from age: at ages 6–9, 18.9% of those with under 40,000 miles failed first time versus 42.6% of those with 100,000–140,000 miles.Inside this age group, higher mileage goes with more failures.
| Age | Odometer | % failing | 95% interval | Tests |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3–5 | <40k miles | 16.8% | 15–18.6% | 1,635 |
| 3–5 | 40-70k miles | 26.5% | 21.8–31.9% | 294 (rough estimate) |
| 6–9 | <40k miles | 18.9% | 18.2–19.7% | 9,865 |
| 6–9 | 40-70k miles | 31.8% | 30.8–32.8% | 7,635 |
| 6–9 | 70-100k miles | 42% | 39.7–44.4% | 1,637 |
| 6–9 | 100-140k miles | 42.6% | 36.7–48.7% | 256 (rough estimate) |
line: median · band: middle half of the fleet (p25–p75)
Mileage by age (p25 / median / p75)
| Age | p25 | Median | p75 | Tests |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | 14,813 | 22,694 | 34,297 | 1,952 |
| 6 | 19,737 | 29,124 | 40,679 | 3,845 |
| 7 | 25,070 | 36,127 | 49,581 | 4,777 |
| 8 | 30,025 | 41,808 | 56,238 | 5,315 |
| 9 | 36,488 | 48,416 | 62,432 | 5,490 |
A typical 8-year-old Forfour has ~41,808 miles on the clock. Much more — ask why; much less — check for gaps in the MOT history.
How do Smart Forfour MOT failure rates vary across Britain?
The failure rate in Paisley (rough estimate) is highest at 32.3%; The failure rate in Nottingham is lowest at 10.9% — the gap is 21.4 percentage points.
higher = larger sharecompare shares in percentage points
| Toughest areas | % failing | 95% interval | Tests | vs model overall |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paisley (PA) | 32.27% rough estimate | 26.79–38.28% | 251 | +11.6 pp |
| Perth (PH) | 31.51% rough estimate | 24.53–39.43% | 146 | +10.8 pp |
| Kirkcaldy (KY) | 30.18% rough estimate | 25.06–35.85% | 275 | +9.5 pp |
| Inverness (IV) | 28.18% rough estimate | 22.65–34.46% | 220 | +7.5 pp |
| Falkirk (FK) | 28.17% rough estimate | 22.56–34.56% | 213 | +7.5 pp |
| Easiest areas | % failing | 95% interval | Tests | vs model overall |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nottingham (NG) | 10.85% | 9.81–11.99% | 3,151 | -9.8 pp |
| Lincoln (LN) | 13.86% rough estimate | 11.4–16.75% | 642 | -6.8 pp |
| Kingston upon Thames (KT) | 13.88% | 12.36–15.57% | 1,779 | -6.8 pp |
| Truro (TR) | 16.21% | 13.97–18.74% | 919 | -4.5 pp |
| Bath (BA) | 16.46% | 14.17–19.04% | 893 | -4.2 pp |
Why do areas differ?
For each external factor we correlate the area fail rate with the factor across postcode areas that have ≥800 tests of this family, then compare the bottom vs top fifth (quintile) of the factor. Correlation, not causation — factors travel together (the north is colder and often poorer; urban areas are denser and less salted). Road surface condition is joined now, for the 91 English areas the DfT publishes, and it explains nothing: the correlation with suspension failures is −0.01 and with body and structure failures 0.07. Potholes wreck wheels and tyres between tests, but by the time a car reaches the bay the road it drives on leaves no measurable trace.
In areas with the highest road-salt proxy this model fails 2.0 pp more often than in the lowest fifth (r=0.27, n=62 areas with ≥800 tests).
In areas with the highest frost days this model fails 2.1 pp more often than in the lowest fifth (r=0.26, n=62 areas with ≥800 tests).
In areas with the highest urban share this model fails 1.9 pp more often than in the lowest fifth (r=0.19, n=62 areas with ≥800 tests).
| Factor | Low Q | High Q | Gap | Correlation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Road-salt proxy | 20.1% | 22.1% | +2.0 pp | r=0.27 |
| Frost days | 19.2% | 21.4% | +2.2 pp | r=0.26 |
| Urban share | 18.8% | 20.7% | +1.9 pp | r=0.19 |
Factors that only mean something combined
Some conditions are useless on their own and informative multiplied together. Frost days alone say little — Britain barely freezes. Salt tonnage alone says little — it tracks frost. Distance to the sea alone says little. Multiply the first two and divide by the third and you get an index of how hard an area attacks a car's underside, and it lines up with the corrosion defects we actually record. We built five such combinations and tested each against our own data. Three survived; two did not, and the failures are listed here on purpose — a proxy that was never checked is decoration. One survivor only survived on the second attempt: built from a crude stand-in for street parking it failed outright, and rebuilt from the census — terraced streets carrying more cars than they have driveways — it works, and carries information the salt index does not.
| Composite | Built from | Tested against | r | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Underbody corrosion | frost days × salt load ÷ (distance to coast + 1) | share of tests with a corrosion defect | +0.42 | holds (116 areas) |
| Tyre wear | rain days × annual miles ÷ age at first tyre advisory | share of tests failing on tyres | +0.45 | holds (116 areas) |
| Overnight corrosion | terraced housing × cars per household × frost days | share with a corrosion defect | +0.41 | holds (102 areas) — and adds signal beyond the first index |
| Deferred maintenance | deprivation × advisory-to-failure conversion ÷ labour rate | cars repeating the same advisory | −0.26 | fails (118 areas) |
| Powertrain stress | engine capacity ÷ kerb weight | suspension, brake and emissions failures | −0.16 | fails (22 models) |
The deprivation result is the one worth dwelling on. The intuition that poorer areas defer repairs is strong enough that most people treat it as established. We tested it twice — once on raw failure rates (r = 0.04) and again, more fairly, on whether an advisory turns into a failure — and it did not hold any of the three times we tried it — on raw failure rates, on advisory-to-failure conversion, and again with deprivation measured properly inside each nation rather than England alone. We are closing it. What does predict local failure rates is the density of test centres, which is a statement about testing, not about cars.
All external-factor correlations (machine-readable)
| Factor | r | n areas | Low-Q fail % | High-Q fail % | Gap pp | Low-Q factor | High-Q factor |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Road-salt proxy (g/m²-yr) | 0.265 | 62 | 20.1 | 22.1 | +2.0 | 207.8 | 476.7 |
| Frost days (days/year) | 0.263 | 62 | 19.2 | 21.4 | +2.1 | 10.8 | 27 |
| Urban share (0–1) | 0.193 | 62 | 18.8 | 20.7 | +1.9 | 0.5 | 1 |
| Terrain gradient (% grade) | 0.173 | 35 | 21.5 | 22.4 | +0.8 | 0.6 | 2.9 |
| MOT centre density (per 10k vehicles) | -0.169 | 62 | 20.7 | 19.1 | -1.6 | 4.9 | 7.7 |
| Distance to coast (km) | -0.105 | 62 | 19.5 | 19.3 | -0.2 | 6.8 | 83.9 |
| Income deprivation (score) | 0.057 | 58 | 20.1 | 20.4 | +0.3 | 0.1 | 0.2 |
Deprivation uses England IMD 2019 income score only (Scotland SIMD is a different scale). Salt proxy is a simplified NWSRG-style dry-salt sum from air Tmin; coastalness is distance from the area centroid to the nearest coastline.
Every dot is a postcode area — size = how many were tested there, colour = share failing. These figures are not age-adjusted: coastal and rural areas often run older fleets and salted roads, so higher raw fail rates do not automatically mean a worse local stock of this model.
Map labels: Scotland · N. England · Wales · London · S. West. Colour scale: 17%–28% failing.
Smart Forfour survival: which cars are still on the road
By age 9 is well below the reference at 26.5%, against 100.0% at the ages 4–6 reference level.
higher = larger sharecompare shares in percentage points
Chart axes: car age, years · survival vs ages 4–6 · scale 0–105%. Values above 100% are plotted at 100%.
Survival vs fail rate by age
| Age | Tests | Survival vs ages 4–6 | Fail % |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | 17,191 | 83% | 11.98% |
| 4 | 21,468 | at least 100% | 18.19% |
| 5 | 21,214 | at least 100% | 19.26% |
| 6 | 19,491 | 94% | 21.45% |
| 7 | 15,634 | 75.4% | 25.02% |
| 8 | 10,864 | 52.4% | 28.93% |
| 9 | 5,490 | 26.5% | 32.39% |
By age 9, only about 26% as many cars of this family present for MOT as at ages 4–6 (reference n≈20,724); survivors still fail at 32.4% vs 18.2% at age 4. Older cars that still appear are a selected subset — weaker ones have already left.
How many miles does a Smart Forfour last?
| Odometer | Tests ≥ threshold | Share of sample | 95% interval |
|---|---|---|---|
| 100,000+ miles | 523 | 0.47% | 0.44–0.52% |
| 150,000+ miles | 41 | 0.04% (rough estimate) | 0.03–0.05% |
| 200,000+ miles | 9 | 0.01% (rough estimate) | 0–0.02% |
of 110,111 tested cars, 523 had reached 100,000 miles, of 110,111 tested cars, 41 had reached 150,000 miles, of 110,111 tested cars, 9 had reached 200,000 miles. This is a cross-section of cars still presenting for MOT, not a full birth cohort.
How many years is a Smart Forfour likely to last?
| Age now | Typical mileage (p50) | Expected years left |
|---|---|---|
| 5 | — | at least 3 |
estimateEstimate only — not a warranty: a typical 5-year-old example of this family has at least 3.0 expected years of further MOT-present life. The curve is observed only until age 9, so the true figure is likely higher.
Smart Forfour faults that come together
Body & structure + Emissions & leaks stand out at 24.00×, against 1.00× if the faults were independent.
above 1.0× = more than expectedbelow 1.0× = less
| Group A | Group B | Together | Lift |
|---|---|---|---|
| Body, chassis, structure | Noise, emissions and leaks | 500 | 24× |
| Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment | Steering | 46 | 7.95× (rough estimate) |
| Steering | Suspension | 49 | 7.85× (rough estimate) |
| Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment | Seat belts and supplementary restraint systems | 40 | 7.33× (rough estimate) |
| Noise, emissions and leaks | Steering | 33 | 7.32× (rough estimate) |
| Body, chassis, structure | Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment | 174 | 6.5× (rough estimate) |
| Identification of the vehicle | Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment | 33 | 6.43× (rough estimate) |
| Noise, emissions and leaks | Seat belts and supplementary restraint systems | 27 | 6.35× (rough estimate) |
| Body, chassis, structure | Suspension | 171 | 5.92× (rough estimate) |
| Brakes | Steering | 30 | 5.7× (rough estimate) |
| Identification of the vehicle | Tyres | 56 | 5.13× (rough estimate) |
| Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment | Noise, emissions and leaks | 384 | 4.96× (rough estimate) |
| Brakes | Seat belts and supplementary restraint systems | 23 | 4.63× (rough estimate) |
| Noise, emissions and leaks | Suspension | 385 | 4.61× (rough estimate) |
| Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment | Suspension | 491 | 4.58× (rough estimate) |
| Brakes | Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment | 395 | 4.37× (rough estimate) |
| Brakes | Tyres | 830 | 4.31× |
| Brakes | Identification of the vehicle | 20 | 4.28× (rough estimate) |
| Body, chassis, structure | Brakes | 104 | 4.27× (rough estimate) |
| Road Wheels | Tyres | 24 | 4.2× (rough estimate) |
| Seat belts and supplementary restraint systems | Suspension | 24 | 4.07× (rough estimate) |
| Steering | Tyres | 50 | 4.06× (rough estimate) |
| Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment | Tyres | 854 | 4.04× |
| Identification of the vehicle | Visibility | 42 | 3.79× (rough estimate) |
| Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment | Visibility | 778 | 3.62× |
| Identification of the vehicle | Suspension | 20 | 3.61× (rough estimate) |
| Body, chassis, structure | Tyres | 204 | 3.58× (rough estimate) |
| Seat belts and supplementary restraint systems | Tyres | 41 | 3.53× (rough estimate) |
| Seat belts and supplementary restraint systems | Visibility | 41 | 3.48× (rough estimate) |
| Road Wheels | Visibility | 20 | 3.45× (rough estimate) |
| Brakes | Visibility | 667 | 3.41× |
| Brakes | Suspension | 333 | 3.41× (rough estimate) |
| Brakes | Noise, emissions and leaks | 238 | 3.38× (rough estimate) |
| Tyres | Visibility | 1,430 | 3.13× |
| Suspension | Tyres | 635 | 2.78× |
| Noise, emissions and leaks | Tyres | 445 | 2.7× (rough estimate) |
| Body, chassis, structure | Visibility | 150 | 2.6× (rough estimate) |
| Noise, emissions and leaks | Visibility | 389 | 2.33× (rough estimate) |
| Suspension | Visibility | 519 | 2.24× |
| Steering | Visibility | 28 | 2.24× (rough estimate) |
| Identification of the vehicle | Noise, emissions and leaks | 15 | too few (rough estimate) |
| Body, chassis, structure | Steering | 14 | too few (rough estimate) |
| Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment | Road Wheels | 14 | too few (rough estimate) |
| Noise, emissions and leaks | Road Wheels | 12 | too few (rough estimate) |
| Body, chassis, structure | Identification of the vehicle | 11 | too few (rough estimate) |
| Brakes | Road Wheels | 10 | too few (rough estimate) |
| Body, chassis, structure | Seat belts and supplementary restraint systems | 8 | too few (rough estimate) |
| Seat belts and supplementary restraint systems | Steering | 6 | too few (rough estimate) |
| Body, chassis, structure | Road Wheels | 6 | too few (rough estimate) |
| Road Wheels | Suspension | 5 | too few (rough estimate) |
Defects in «Body, chassis, structure» and «Noise, emissions and leaks» appear together 24.00× more often than chance (500 co-occurrences in the same test; 78 pairs compared).
Lift = how many times more often both groups appear on the same test than if independent. A pair is listed from 5 tests with both faults; the lift is shown from 20, and called above chance only when its 95% interval excludes 1 (see rough estimates).
Is low mileage better for a Smart Forfour?
Cars driven under 5,000 miles a year is well below the reference at 17.5%, against 32.2% for cars driven 8,000–12,000 miles a year.
higher = larger sharecompare shares in percentage points
| Band | Fail % | Tests |
|---|---|---|
| <5k miles/year | 17.52% | 32,631 |
| 8–12k miles/year | 32.17% | 10,585 |
| Gap (low − normal) | -14.64 pp | — |
By fuel and age
Petrol
| Age | Low-use fail % | n | Normal fail % | n | Gap pp |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | 14.04 | 9,442 | 26.27 | 3,205 | -12.23 pp |
| 6 | 16.32 | 8,685 | 29.72 | 2,860 | -13.4 pp |
| 7 | 18.67 | 6,872 | 33.92 | 2,276 | -15.25 pp |
| 8 | 22.63 | 4,768 | 40.35 | 1,502 | -17.72 pp |
| 9 | 23.41 | 2,345 | 45.84 | 709 | -22.43 pp |
At matched ages 5–14, cars averaging under 5k miles/year fail at 17.5% vs 32.2% for 8–12k miles/year — 14.6 pp lower (n_low=32,631, n_normal=10,585). In this family low annual use is associated with fewer MOT fails, not more — the ‘garage queen’ penalty is not visible in overall fail rates.
Best year for a Smart Forfour, and the years to avoid
Build year 2015 is highest at 105.6; Build year 2019 is lowest at 92.3 — the gap is 13.3 points.
below 100 is betterabove 100 is worse100 = normal for this model at that age
build year vs the same model at the same age · 100 = as expected
Every build year with its confidence interval
| Build year | vs own age norm | 95% CI | Raw fail % | Tests | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | 92.3 | 86.2–98.4 | 14.7% | 5,911 | better |
| 2018 | 94.4 | 90.7–98.1 | 16.29% | 15,417 | better |
| 2017 | 98.2 | 95.3–101 | 18.1% | 25,286 | no different |
| 2016 | 102.7 | 100.2–105.1 | 21.19% | 31,503 | worse |
| 2015 | 105.6 | 103.3–107.9 | 25.38% | 33,221 | worse |
The best build year here is 2019 and the weakest is 2015. Comparing build years sounds simple and is not: within a single year of testing, a car's build year and its age are the same number, so a naive comparison of years is a comparison of ages wearing a disguise. Each year below is measured against the same model at the same age in other cohorts, across six years of testing — 4 of 5 years come out distinguishable from their own model's age norm.
Two limits worth knowing before you act on this. Age, test year and build year are locked together by arithmetic, so the test-year effect is taken from the observed national failure level of each year rather than estimated — it is an adjustment, not a solution.
Smart Forfour MOT repair costs
The MOT-failure repair budget per test runs from £33.18 to £63.04, against £54.85 for the test itself.
bigger number = costs morepounds per test, MOT-failing faults only
| Component | Fails per 100 tests | Typical repair | Its price | Contribution |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tyres | 9.2 (nat. 8.7) | Tyre (single mid-range 16" fitted) | £90 | £8.28 |
| Suspension | 4.0 (nat. 15.36) | Suspension coil spring (single corner) | £180 | £7.20 |
| Noise, emissions and leaks | 3.2 (nat. 3.67) | Exhaust rear silencer | £200 | £6.40 |
| Brakes | 3.8 (nat. 11.25) | Front brake pads (parts + labour, typical hatchback) | £150 | £5.70 |
| Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment | 4.0 (nat. 18.09) | Battery replacement (standard 12V lead-acid) | £140 | £5.60 |
Multiply how often each component fails on this model by what that repair usually costs, and you get the amount an owner should expect to budget per test for MOT-failing faults only — roughly £33 to £63, on top of the test fee itself. It is a budgeting figure, not a quote: the spread between a set of pads and a set of discs is most of the range.
Prices are modal quotes from a hand-kept catalogue of published UK garage guides — we do not scrape the booking sites, their terms forbid it, so this list is short and updated by hand with a source and date against each line. Each line prices one typical repair in that group, not a full remedy, and only groups our catalogue actually covers are counted. The contrast worth noticing is the second card: the legal maximum for the test has been £54.85 since 2010, while the repairs it uncovers have followed inflation the whole time.
For scale from a different direction: Warrantywise, which sees used-car warranty claims rather than test failures, puts the average claim at £2,052 across the ten highest-claim models it ranks and £539 for Honda, the lowest-claim make in its index (Warrantywise index 2026, 1.6 million claims, cars aged 3–15). Those sit an order of magnitude above the figures in this table, and the gap is the point: a warranty claim is a gearbox or an engine, which almost never fails an MOT, while the faults that do fail one are corrosion, lamps and tyres, which no warranty pays for. The two numbers answer different questions and neither replaces the other.
Smart Forfour running costs for a fleet
Vehicles failing at age 9 stand out at 32.0%, against 18.0% at age 5, tested in the same year.
higher = larger sharecompare shares in percentage points
Failure rate and typical odometer by age
| Age | Fails | Median odometer | Tests | Gap vs age 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | 18.49% | 22,694 | 1,952 | +0.0 pp |
| 6 | 18.8% | 29,124 | 3,845 | +0.3 pp |
| 7 | 23.24% | 36,127 | 4,777 | +4.8 pp |
| 8 | 28.18% | 41,808 | 5,315 | +9.7 pp |
| 9 | 32.39% | 48,416 | 5,490 | +13.9 pp |
The number a fleet manager needs is not the failure rate, it is the year the car starts costing more. Between cars aged 7 and cars aged 8, both tested in 2024, the failure rate of this model is 4.94 percentage points higher — the steepest one-year step in this cross-section of different cars, and a natural planning point for replacement.
Repair spend uses the same modal prices as the section above, so it inherits the same limits: one typical repair per component group, not a full remedy. Downtime is the gap between the failed test and the passed re-test, which is the window a vehicle is legally off the road.
Smart Forfour rust problems: where they corrode
Age-standardised corrosion susceptibility is well below the reference at <0.1×, against 1.00× for the national age-standardised rate.
above 1.0× = rusts more than averagebelow 1.0× = rusts less
This Smart Forfour virtually never fails on corrosion once age is held constant, and its owners live in areas that are about typical for the models we publish.
Corrosion is the one failure mode that is as much about geography as about the car. We keep the two apart on purpose: a model can look rusty simply because it is popular in Scotland, and a model can look clean simply because it is bought in Surrey. Blending them into a single score would hide which of the two is doing the work.
Exposure is this model's tests weighted by an area corrosion index built from frost days, salt load and distance to the coast — the composite validated at r = 0.42 against corrosion defects we actually record. It is published as a rank, not a raw score, because every mainstream model skews towards low-corrosion areas for the simple reason that most of Britain's cars are in the south. Susceptibility is standardised to the national age profile, so an old fleet does not get labelled a rusty model.
Does a Smart Forfour advisory become a failure?
Suspension is highest at 17.4%; Non-component advisories are lowest at 0.0% — the gap is 17.4 percentage points.
higher = more likelypercentage is the observed transition probability
chance the same component fails at the next MOT, given an advisory now
| Component | Fails next time | Typical lead time | Miles of warning | Advisories tracked |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Suspension | 17.4% | 12 months | 5,910 | 2,123 |
| Tyres | 11.0% | 12 months | 6,051 | 19,950 |
| Brakes | 7.2% | 12 months | 5,813 | 12,087 |
| Noise, emissions and leaks | 6.5% | 12 months | 3,372 | 647 |
| Identification of the vehicle | 3.0% | 12 months | 8,032 | 526 |
| Road wheels | 0.8% | 14.9 months | 9,570 | 520 |
| Non-component advisories | 0.0% | — | — | 3,863 |
This is the question an advisory note actually raises, and it needs six years of test history to answer. We followed the same vehicles from one MOT to the next across 2019–2024 and measured how often a component that was merely advised came back as a genuine failure at the next test.
Read it as a budgeting horizon, not a prophecy: the most likely component above turns into a failure for about 17 in 100 cars, and the median gap is 12 months and roughly 5,910 miles. The rest were repaired, sold, scrapped, or simply held. Rows with fewer than 500 tracked advisories are not shown.
What will fail next on a Smart Forfour?
Suspension after a failure at age 9-11 is highest at 15.8%; Brakes after a passed at age <3 are lowest at 1.4% — the gap is 14.4 percentage points.
higher = more likelypercentage is the observed transition probability
| Age | Last test | Most likely next failures | Cars tracked |
|---|---|---|---|
| <3 | passed | Visibility 7.6% · Tyres 4.0% · Brakes 1.4% | 8,532 |
| <3 | advisory | Visibility 9.0% · Tyres 8.3% · Brakes 2.9% | 1,716 |
| <3 | failure | Visibility 9.5% · Tyres 6.6% · Brakes 2.9% | 1,069 |
| 3-5 | passed | Visibility 5.5% · Tyres 4.9% · Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment 2.1% | 31,795 |
| 3-5 | advisory | Tyres 8.7% · Visibility 7.8% · Brakes 4.2% | 12,971 |
| 3-5 | failure | Tyres 9.5% · Visibility 7.9% · Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment 4.5% | 10,362 |
| 6-8 | passed | Suspension 6.2% · Tyres 5.7% · Visibility 5.3% | 10,936 |
| 6-8 | advisory | Tyres 9.6% · Suspension 8.4% · Visibility 7.0% | 6,607 |
| 6-8 | failure | Suspension 10.9% · Tyres 9.9% · Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment 8.6% | 6,207 |
| 9-11 | failure | Suspension 15.8% · Noise, emissions and leaks 10.5% | 57 (rough estimate) |
The same chains, cut differently: given a car's age and how its last test went, which component most often causes trouble at the following one.
The pattern that repeats across every family: a failure at one test roughly doubles the chance of a failure on the same component at the next one, and an advisory sits about half-way between a clean pass and a failure. Age bands in years; probabilities are per car, not per defect item.
Smart Forfour ownership: what six years of MOTs show
The share of successful retests 1–10 days after failure is highest at 49.1%; The share of successful retests more than 10 days after failure is lowest at 2.1% — the gap is 46.9 percentage points.
higher = larger sharecompare shares in percentage points
We followed 16,017 failed initial tests to their first recorded successful retest. Of those successful retests, 48.81% took place the same day, 49.05% took place 1–10 days later and 2.14% took place more than 10 days later. The median wait was 1 day. 30,449 defect items were cleared in the process.
Per mile driven, not per year. Dividing failures by the miles that actually went onto the odometers between consecutive tests gives 0.425 failures per 10,000 miles, on a median of 4,274 miles a year across 21,651 chains. This is the number to compare between models — an annual rate quietly rewards cars that barely leave the drive.
Two populations hide inside one model. 50.69% of these cars strung together three or more tests with nothing recorded at all, while 16.99% carried the same advisory three times or more — the same fault, noted, ignored, noted again. When you buy used you are buying one of those two histories, and the MOT record shows which.
Odometer anomalies: 0.938% of 21,653 chains show a reading lower than the previous test, with a median drop of 10,078 miles. We call this an anomaly and not fraud on purpose — instrument swaps, imports, unit mix-ups and keying errors all land in the same bucket. Obvious typos (drops under 100 miles or over 90% of the reading) are already excluded.
Smart Forfour MOT: quick answers
Smart Forfour MOT Risk Index stands out at 118.2, against 100 for a car with the same age profile.
below 100 is betterabove 100 is worse100 = normal for this model at that age
- What is the Smart Forfour first-time MOT pass rate?
- 74.42% of first attempts passed in 2024 (21,386 tests). Basis: first-time, excluding retests. The final pass rate on those initial tests was 79.9%, including 5.4% fixed at the test centre.
- Why does this number differ from other sites?
- Other sites often report a pass rate that includes retests or counts all attempts. Our 25.58% figure is the first-time initial failure rate, using 21,386 primary tests as the denominator (first-time, excluding retests). The age-adjusted MOT initial-failure ratio 118.2 is shown separately because raw rates compare fleet age as well as cars.
Compare the Smart Forfour with other cars
Nissan Qashqai is highest at 118.2; Mercedes-Benz Vito is lowest at 117.7 — the gap is 0.5 points.
below 100 is betterabove 100 is worse100 = normal for this model at that age
Same brand
Similar risk
Nissan Qashqai (index 118.2)Citroën Xsara (index 117.9)Mercedes-Benz Vito (index 117.7)
Same size class
how Mercedes-Benz SL compareshow Citroën C4 Cactus compareshow Toyota Land Cruiser compares
Download this model’s data (CSV)
Data details, citation and corrections
Scope: class-4 vehicles (cars), initial tests only, outcomes pass / fail / fixed-on-the-spot at the station (PRS counts towards the failure rate — the defect was present at arrival). Index = observed initial failures ÷ failures expected for this fleet's exact age profile, ×100; margin of error is a 95% confidence interval. The figures describe the tested vehicles assigned to this model. Dataset release dataset_release_id=dvsa-2024-v2, frozen baseline; headline claim_id=family-stats:smart-forfour:dvsa-2024-v2. Full method: methodology.
How to cite this page
MOT Risk Index (2026). Smart Forfour MOT statistics 2024 (data release dvsa-2024-v2; full dataset motriskindex-families-2024-v5, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.22975051), updated 24 September 2026. motriskindex.co.uk/cars/smart-forfour/
How the MOT Risk Index and every figure on this page are calculated: methodology.
Report an error
What is wrong on this page? One tap sends the category only, no text and nothing about you.
More on the Smart Forfour
- Overview:
- Model overview · All Smart models
- What fails:
- body · brakes · plates · lights · emissions · wheels · seat belts · steering · suspension · tyres · visibility
- By area:
- Postcode areas